Mr. Football Top 50 Composite Rankings FINAL

[GardenStateBaller]

[GardenStateBaller]

The Worst Ranking Award:

Tie: SI has SJB at #14 in its final poll and BC #5. How is either possible??

[Centralpc]

Jserra DF EK Kahuku Greenwood SJP SM Celina Cita Allen St. Louis Vandegrift Coppell Avon and Bixby have no right to be in any top 25

Also, how is Spalding not ranked in Massey 

Edited January 8 by Centralpc

[Omaha Vol]

7 minutes ago, Centralpc said:

Jserra DF EK Kahuku Greenwood SJP SM Celina Cita Allen St. Louis Vandegrift Coppell Avon and Bixby have no right to be in any top 25

Also, how is Spalding not ranked in Massey 

Coppell does. Only loss to N. Crowley. Didn’t get blown like others. 
 

Spalding should be in there as well. 

[Centralpc]

9 minutes ago, Omaha Vol said:

Coppell does. Only loss to N. Crowley. Didn’t get blown like others. 
 

Spalding should be in there as well. 

Coppell I can see more than others for sure. I was just thinking off the top of my head

[GardenStateBaller]

10 minutes ago, Centralpc said:

Coppell I can see more than others for sure. I was just thinking off the top of my head

Rule #1: Gotta play a national schedule to be ranked nationally. 

[Omaha Vol]

12 minutes ago, GardenStateBaller said:

Rule #1: Gotta play a national schedule to be ranked nationally. 

Definitely not rule #1. SOS should be rule #1 (doesn’t necessarily have to be national). 

[Bodysurf]

40 minutes ago, Omaha Vol said:

Definitely not rule #1. SOS should be rule #1 (doesn’t necessarily have to be national). 

Amen! SOS is what matters. Who cares whether your opponents are local or on the other side of the country as long as they are good.

[GardenStateBaller]

7 hours ago, Bodysurf said:

Amen! SOS is what matters. Who cares whether your opponents are local or on the other side of the country as long as they are good.

Milton is def happy they scheduled and beat AHP. Made them the #1 Public Program in America in 2024!!! 

[Bodysurf]

1 hour ago, GardenStateBaller said:

Milton is def happy they scheduled and beat AHP. Made them the #1 Public Program in America in 2024!!! 

My point is that it doesn’t matter where AHP is located. What matters is that AHP is good. It would have helped Milton just as much, if not more, to play another top team in Georgia that is actually ranked higher than AHP. The fact that they travelled across a state line means little. 

[GardenStateBaller]

1 hour ago, Bodysurf said:

My point is that it doesn’t matter where AHP is located. What matters is that AHP is good. It would have helped Milton just as much, if not more, to play another top team in Georgia that is actually ranked higher than AHP. The fact that they travelled across a state line means little. 

Not true as I personally speak with many of the top pollsters in America. At least one win vs an elite, OOS team is required for a MNC or Top 3-5 team nationally. Go back 5+ seasons and see for yourself. 

[Bodysurf]

14 minutes ago, GardenStateBaller said:

Not true as I personally speak with many of the top pollsters in America. At least one win vs an elite, OOS team is required for a MNC or Top 3-5 team nationally. Go back 5+ seasons and see for yourself. 

You place too much importance on OOS. You can't tell me that is better to play an average team in a different state instead of a great team in your own backyard. I fail the see the relevance of where a team is located. All that matters is how good they are. I would agree, that if an elite team is unable to find quality local games, then they have no choice but to travel a greater distance. This is the unfortunate situation that MD is in. We are forced to play OOS to fill our schedule, but we would rather not. Case in point, it is better for MD to play teams like Centennial, Mission, etc versus whoever they can get from a different state. Unless the teams from the different state are actually better. That is my point.

[GardenStateBaller]

9 minutes ago, Bodysurf said:

You place too much importance on OOS. You can't tell me that is better to play an average team in a different state instead of a great team in your own backyard. I fail the see the relevance of where a team is located. All that matters is how good they are. I would agree, that if an elite team is unable to find quality local games, then they have no choice but to travel a greater distance. This is the unfortunate situation that MD is in. We are forced to play OOS to fill our schedule, but we would rather not. Case in point, it is better for MD to play teams like Centennial, Mission, etc versus whoever they can get from a different state. Unless the teams from the different state are actually better. That is my point.

I'm just telling you how the majority of the reputable pollsters think and operate. 

[GardenStateBaller]

10 minutes ago, Bodysurf said:

You place too much importance on OOS. You can't tell me that is better to play an average team in a different state instead of a great team in your own backyard. I fail the see the relevance of where a team is located. All that matters is how good they are. I would agree, that if an elite team is unable to find quality local games, then they have no choice but to travel a greater distance. This is the unfortunate situation that MD is in. We are forced to play OOS to fill our schedule, but we would rather not. Case in point, it is better for MD to play teams like Centennial, Mission, etc versus whoever they can get from a different state. Unless the teams from the different state are actually better. That is my point.

MD won the MNC this season mainly due to it's wins vs BG and SFA. If they had scheduled and beat local teams like Esperanza and Warren instead of those elites, Milton probably finishes #1 in a few polls. 

[Bodysurf]

3 minutes ago, GardenStateBaller said:

I'm just telling you how the majority of the reputable pollsters think and operate. 

Faulty logic. They can think that. I would rather play better local team than waste our budget to play some team in a different state that is not as good.

Perhaps opinion pollsters are impressed that a team steps on a plane. But I would think that a computer considers wins against teams like Cen10 and Bosco as better.

[GardenStateBaller]

2 minutes ago, Bodysurf said:

Faulty logic. They can think that. I would rather play better local team than waste our budget to play some team in a different state that is not as good.

Perhaps opinion pollsters are impressed that a team steps on a plane. But I would think that a computer considers wins against teams like Cen10 and Bosco as better.

You can love on those computer polls all you like!!! LOL SOS matters. 

[Bodysurf]

4 minutes ago, GardenStateBaller said:

MD won the MNC this season mainly due to it's wins vs BG and SFA. If they had scheduled and beat local teams like Esperanza and Warren instead of those elites, Milton probably finishes #1 in a few polls. 

Come on. I'm not talking about crappy local teams and you know that. Every team that MD played except Servite was in the top 50 composite poll. It wasn't just those 2 games. It was the complete schedule. Playing Bosco helped our ranking in computers more than SFA. I agree that Gorman was the best win BY FAR.

[Bodysurf]

1 minute ago, GardenStateBaller said:

You can love on those computer polls all you like!!! LOL SOS matters. 

Exactly! SOS is most important. Not where games are played. That is why Bosco is a better win than SFA. 

[GardenStateBaller]

9 minutes ago, Bodysurf said:

Exactly! SOS is most important. Not where games are played. That is why Bosco is a better win than SFA. 

Your own coaches agree that SFA was the best team MD played this season. I'm excited to celebrate with all of them at your banquet on Saturday at 11am!! 

[Omaha Vol]

16 minutes ago, GardenStateBaller said:

Your own coaches agree that SFA was the best team MD played this season. I'm excited to celebrate with all of them at your banquet on Saturday at 11am!! 

But they weren’t. BG was the best team they played. Hell, BG destroyed the same team (OLu) that beat SFA. Yes, I know OLu played on the road the very next week after a tough game. They still got blown out. All of those top teams played great schedules and earned their rankings. 

[Omaha Vol]

48 minutes ago, GardenStateBaller said:

MD won the MNC this season mainly due to it's wins vs BG and SFA. If they had scheduled and beat local teams like Esperanza and Warren instead of those elites, Milton probably finishes #1 in a few polls. 

But, but, but, wait. With your logic how in the world is N. Crowley ranked ahead of teams like SFA and IMG in your poll? They didn’t play one single OOS team. I’m confused here? 

[GardenStateBaller]

15 minutes ago, Omaha Vol said:

But, but, but, wait. With your logic how in the world is N. Crowley ranked ahead of teams like SFA and IMG in your poll? They didn’t play one single OOS team. I’m confused here? 

Easy peasy. NC beat DV, who beat SFA, who beat IMG. In that respect NCs ceiling was #5 in our poll, which they attained. They had ABSOLUTELY NO SHOT of winning a MNC in this respect.