whiteshoes1212 Posted September 9 Share Posted September 9 1. Santa Ana (CA) Mater Dei (2-0) 2. Bellflower (CA) St. John Bosco (3-0) 3. Las Vegas (NV) Bishop Gorman (2-1) 4. Milton (GA) (3-0) 5. Duncanville (TX) (1-0) 6. Fort Lauderdale (FL) St. Thomas Aquinas (2-1) 7. Houston (TX) North Shore (2-0) 8. Bradenton (FL) IMG Academy (2-1) 9. Peoria (AZ) Liberty (2-0) 10. Austin (TX) Westlake (2-0) 11. Mission Viejo (CA) (3-0) 12. DeSoto (TX) (1-1) 13. Hollywood (FL) Chaminade-Madonna (1-2) 14. Phenix City (AL) Central (3-0) 15. Oradell (NJ) Bergen Catholic (1-1) 16. Orange (CA) Lutheran (3-0) 17. Carrollton (GA) (4-0) 18. Severn (MD) Archbishop Spalding (3-0) 19. Southlake (TX) Carroll (2-0) 20. Baltimore (MD) St. Francis Academy (2-1) 21. Lakewood (OH) St. Edward (2-1) 22. Plantation (FL) American Heritage (1-2) 23. Humble (TX) Atascocita (2-0) 24. Buford (GA) (2-1) 25. Cocoa (FL) (2-1) 26. Massillon (OH) Washington (2-1) 27. Fort Worth (TX) North Crowley (2-0) 28. Belleville (MI) (2-0) 29. Concord (CA) De LaSalle (2-0) 30. Highland (UT) Lone Peak (4-0) 31. Philadelphia (PA) St. Joseph Prep (1-1) 32. Danville (KY) Boyle County (3-0) 33. Lakeland (FL) (2-0) 34. Houston (TX) Summer Creek (2-0) 35. Miami (FL) Central (2-1) 36. San Juan Capistrano (CA) J Serra Catholic (3-0) 37. Draper (UT) Corner Canyon (3-1) 38. Suwanee (GA) North Gwinnett (3-0) 39. Olney (MD) Our Lady of Good Counsel (1-1) 40. Miami (FL) Norland (2-0) 41. Philadelphia (PA) Imhotep Charter (3-0) 42. Pinson (AL) Clay-Chalkville (3-0) 43. Bryant (AR) (2-0) 44. Thomasville (GA) Thomas County Central (4-0) 45. Hyattsville (MD) DeMatha (0-1) 46. Anaheim (CA) Servite (3-0) 47. Hochston (GA) Mill Creek (3-1) 48. Rancho Santa Margarita (CA) Santa Margarita (2-1) 49. Ruston (LA) (1-0) 50. Mililani (HI) (4-0) 51. Akron (OH) Archbishop Hoban (2-1) 52. Saraland (AL) (3-0) 53. Corona (CA) Centennial (1-2) 54. Denton (TX) Guyer (2-0) 55. San Mateo (CA) Serra (1-1) 56. Norman Park (GA) Colquitt County (2-1) 57. Trophy Club (TX) Byron Nelson (2-0) 58. Alabaster (AL) Thompson (2-1) 59. Chandler (AZ) (2-0) 60. Brownsburg (IN) (3-0) 61. Folsom (CA) (1-1) 62. East St. Louis (IL) (2-0) 63. Longview (TX) (2-0) 64. Kahuku (HI) (3-1) 65. Chattanooga (TN) Baylor (3-0) 66. Cibolo (TX) Steele (2-0) 67. Cincinnati (OH) Archbishop Moeller (3-0) 68. Seffner (FL) Armwood (3-0) 69. Katy (TX) (1-1) 70. Venice (FL) (3-0) 71. Greensboro (NC) Grimsley (3-0) 72. Kingsland (GA) Camden County (4-0) 73. Aledo (TX) (1-1) 74. Portland (OR) Central Catholic (2-0) 75. Norfolk (VA) Maury (1-0) 76. Rabun Gap (GA) Rabun Gap-Nacoochee (3-1) 77. Matthews (NC) Weddington (3-0) 78. St. Louis (MO) Cardinal Ritter Prep (2-0) 79. Chandler (AZ) Hamilton (2-0) 80. Loganville (GA) Grayson (3-1) 81. Chatsworth (CA) Sierra Canyon (2-2) 82. Littleton (CO) Columbine (2-0) 83. Lehi (UT) (3-0) 84. Anderson (SC) Westside (2-0) 85. Las Vegas (NV) Arbor View (3-0) 86. Lehi (UT) Skybridge (3-1) 87. Douglas (GA) Coffee (3-0) 88. Lafayette (LA) St. Thomas More (1-0) 89. Nashville (TN) Christ Presbyterian Academy (3-0) 90. Frankfort (IL) Lincoln-Way East (1-0) 91. Wayne (NJ) DePaul Catholic (2-0) 92. Rock Hill (SC) Northwestern (2-0) 93. Avon (OH) (3-0) 94. Hattiesburg (MS) Oak Grove (2-0) 95. Auburn (AL) (3-0) 96. Irmo (SC) Dutch Fork (2-0) 97. Germantown (TN) Houston (3-0) 98. Franklin (WI) (3-0) 99. Little Rock (AR) Parkview (2-0) 100. Martinsburg (WV) (2-0) 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
elKakador Posted September 9 Share Posted September 9 2 hours ago, whiteshoes1212 said: 1. Santa Ana (CA) Mater Dei (2-0) 2. Bellflower (CA) St. John Bosco (3-0) 3. Las Vegas (NV) Bishop Gorman (2-1) 4. Milton (GA) (3-0) 5. Duncanville (TX) (1-0) 6. Fort Lauderdale (FL) St. Thomas Aquinas (2-1) 7. Houston (TX) North Shore (2-0) 8. Bradenton (FL) IMG Academy (2-1) 9. Peoria (AZ) Liberty (2-0) 10. Austin (TX) Westlake (2-0) 11. Mission Viejo (CA) (3-0) 12. DeSoto (TX) (1-1) 13. Hollywood (FL) Chaminade-Madonna (1-2) 14. Phenix City (AL) Central (3-0) 15. Oradell (NJ) Bergen Catholic (1-1) 16. Orange (CA) Lutheran (3-0) 17. Carrollton (GA) (4-0) 18. Severn (MD) Archbishop Spalding (3-0) 19. Southlake (TX) Carroll (2-0) 20. Baltimore (MD) St. Francis Academy (2-1) 21. Lakewood (OH) St. Edward (2-1) 22. Plantation (FL) American Heritage (1-2) 23. Humble (TX) Atascocita (2-0) 24. Buford (GA) (2-1) 25. Cocoa (FL) (2-1) 26. Massillon (OH) Washington (2-1) 27. Fort Worth (TX) North Crowley (2-0) 28. Belleville (MI) (2-0) 29. Concord (CA) De LaSalle (2-0) 30. Highland (UT) Lone Peak (4-0) 31. Philadelphia (PA) St. Joseph Prep (1-1) 32. Danville (KY) Boyle County (3-0) 33. Lakeland (FL) (2-0) 34. Houston (TX) Summer Creek (2-0) 35. Miami (FL) Central (2-1) 36. San Juan Capistrano (CA) J Serra Catholic (3-0) 37. Draper (UT) Corner Canyon (3-1) 38. Suwanee (GA) North Gwinnett (3-0) 39. Olney (MD) Our Lady of Good Counsel (1-1) 40. Miami (FL) Norland (2-0) 41. Philadelphia (PA) Imhotep Charter (3-0) 42. Pinson (AL) Clay-Chalkville (3-0) 43. Bryant (AR) (2-0) 44. Thomasville (GA) Thomas County Central (4-0) 45. Hyattsville (MD) DeMatha (0-1) 46. Anaheim (CA) Servite (3-0) 47. Hochston (GA) Mill Creek (3-1) 48. Rancho Santa Margarita (CA) Santa Margarita (2-1) 49. Ruston (LA) (1-0) 50. Mililani (HI) (4-0) 51. Akron (OH) Archbishop Hoban (2-1) 52. Saraland (AL) (3-0) 53. Corona (CA) Centennial (1-2) 54. Denton (TX) Guyer (2-0) 55. San Mateo (CA) Serra (1-1) 56. Norman Park (GA) Colquitt County (2-1) 57. Trophy Club (TX) Byron Nelson (2-0) 58. Alabaster (AL) Thompson (2-1) 59. Chandler (AZ) (2-0) 60. Brownsburg (IN) (3-0) 61. Folsom (CA) (1-1) 62. East St. Louis (IL) (2-0) 63. Longview (TX) (2-0) 64. Kahuku (HI) (3-1) 65. Chattanooga (TN) Baylor (3-0) 66. Cibolo (TX) Steele (2-0) 67. Cincinnati (OH) Archbishop Moeller (3-0) 68. Seffner (FL) Armwood (3-0) 69. Katy (TX) (1-1) 70. Venice (FL) (3-0) 71. Greensboro (NC) Grimsley (3-0) 72. Kingsland (GA) Camden County (4-0) 73. Aledo (TX) (1-1) 74. Portland (OR) Central Catholic (2-0) 75. Norfolk (VA) Maury (1-0) 76. Rabun Gap (GA) Rabun Gap-Nacoochee (3-1) 77. Matthews (NC) Weddington (3-0) 78. St. Louis (MO) Cardinal Ritter Prep (2-0) 79. Chandler (AZ) Hamilton (2-0) 80. Loganville (GA) Grayson (3-1) 81. Chatsworth (CA) Sierra Canyon (2-2) 82. Littleton (CO) Columbine (2-0) 83. Lehi (UT) (3-0) 84. Anderson (SC) Westside (2-0) 85. Las Vegas (NV) Arbor View (3-0) 86. Lehi (UT) Skybridge (3-1) 87. Douglas (GA) Coffee (3-0) 88. Lafayette (LA) St. Thomas More (1-0) 89. Nashville (TN) Christ Presbyterian Academy (3-0) 90. Frankfort (IL) Lincoln-Way East (1-0) 91. Wayne (NJ) DePaul Catholic (2-0) 92. Rock Hill (SC) Northwestern (2-0) 93. Avon (OH) (3-0) 94. Hattiesburg (MS) Oak Grove (2-0) 95. Auburn (AL) (3-0) 96. Irmo (SC) Dutch Fork (2-0) 97. Germantown (TN) Houston (3-0) 98. Franklin (WI) (3-0) 99. Little Rock (AR) Parkview (2-0) 100. Martinsburg (WV) (2-0) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
elKakador Posted September 9 Share Posted September 9 Interesting that Good Counsel is 39 here and DePaul 91. I guess head-to-head meetings don't count in determining rankings in this poll. Intriguing new approach to ranking! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
whiteshoes1212 Posted September 9 Author Share Posted September 9 20 minutes ago, elKakador said: Interesting that Good Counsel is 39 here and DePaul 91. I guess head-to-head meetings don't count in determining rankings in this poll. Intriguing new approach to ranking! Goes back to the best of ten theory. IMO if these teams played ten times, Good Counsel would most likely win the majority to the games. It is not new; it is the way I have always measured teams. How many times in a rematch later in the season does the loser of the first game, win the second one. So many factors go into a one game scenario that to say one team is superior as reflected in the one game is a tough call. For instance, it is hard to imagine that Fort Worth North Crowley could be DeSoto again as everything fell their way in the first game. The season will determine if Counsel is overrated at this point or if DePaul Catholic was underrated. That is the essence of why we rank teams each week to reflect the changes brought out during the season. Stay tuned!! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
elKakador Posted September 9 Share Posted September 9 2 minutes ago, whiteshoes1212 said: Goes back to the best of ten theory. IMO if these teams played ten times, Good Counsel would most likely win the majority to the games. It is not new; it is the way I have always measured teams. How many times in a rematch later in the season does the loser of the first game, win the second one. So many factors go into a one game scenario that to say one team is superior as reflected in the one game is a tough call. For instance, it is hard to imagine that Fort Worth North Crowley could be DeSoto again as everything fell their way in the first game. The season will determine if Counsel is overrated at this point or if DePaul Catholic was underrated. That is the essence of why we rank teams each week to reflect the changes brought out during the season. Stay tuned!! So what you're saying is it's completely subjective. What would be the outcome if they played again this year, next year, 10 years from now. That's something that's easy to figure out! We can disregard what actually happened between the teams if we feel it goes against what we think should be the case. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GardenStateBaller Posted September 9 Share Posted September 9 26 minutes ago, whiteshoes1212 said: Goes back to the best of ten theory. IMO if these teams played ten times, Good Counsel would most likely win the majority to the games. It is not new; it is the way I have always measured teams. How many times in a rematch later in the season does the loser of the first game, win the second one. So many factors go into a one game scenario that to say one team is superior as reflected in the one game is a tough call. For instance, it is hard to imagine that Fort Worth North Crowley could be DeSoto again as everything fell their way in the first game. The season will determine if Counsel is overrated at this point or if DePaul Catholic was underrated. That is the essence of why we rank teams each week to reflect the changes brought out during the season. Stay tuned!! Did you watch the game like the rest of us? DPC is def the better team overall. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
elKakador Posted September 9 Share Posted September 9 1 hour ago, GardenStateBaller said: Did you watch the game like the rest of us? DPC is def the better team overall. Was at the game... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GardenStateBaller Posted September 9 Share Posted September 9 2 minutes ago, elKakador said: Was at the game... I watched it on Flo from Auburn, AL!! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
elKakador Posted September 9 Share Posted September 9 12 minutes ago, GardenStateBaller said: I watched it on Flo from Auburn, AL!! 12 minutes ago, GardenStateBaller said: I watched it on Flo from Auburn, AL!! I should add that GC is really a class act! After all, they were the ones with the national reputation, not DePaul,. They did DePaul a service by coming up to Wayne to play the game. They could have insisted that if DePaul wanted the game (and I know for sure that DePaul initiated contact here about the game) they would have to go to Maryland to play it. Nor did they become chippy when it became clear they would not win, as some teams do... As I said a class act! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GardenStateBaller Posted September 10 Share Posted September 10 13 minutes ago, elKakador said: I should add that GC is really a class act! After all, they were the ones with the national reputation, not DePaul,. They did DePaul a service by coming up to Wayne to play the game. They could have insisted that if DePaul wanted the game (and I know for sure that DePaul initiated contact here about the game) they would have to go to Maryland to play it. Nor did they become chippy when it became clear they would not win, as some teams do... As I said a class act! Hoping DPC returns the favor next season. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Sammy Swordsman Posted September 10 Share Posted September 10 White shoes>No nonsense Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GardenStateBaller Posted September 10 Share Posted September 10 20 hours ago, elKakador said: Interesting that Good Counsel is 39 here and DePaul 91. I guess head-to-head meetings don't count in determining rankings in this poll. Intriguing new approach to ranking! He did the same with NC/DeSoto. Why play the games if H2H doesn't matter? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
whiteshoes1212 Posted September 11 Author Share Posted September 11 On 9/9/2024 at 6:26 PM, GardenStateBaller said: Did you watch the game like the rest of us? DPC is def the better team overall. Actually, did not. Watched several other games in addition to trying to secure a playoff spot for the Minnesota Twins. However, I depend on input from people who did to get feedback on the game. It appears that both of you think that DePaul Catholic was not only the better team that day but would be the better team on most days. That information is now in the "vault" which I will carry forward from this day on. I respect what you say and will add it to my considerations in my polling. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
whiteshoes1212 Posted September 11 Author Share Posted September 11 18 hours ago, GardenStateBaller said: He did the same with NC/DeSoto. Why play the games if H2H doesn't matter? Unlike the DePaul-Good Counsel game, this is one that I firmly believe was an outlier. If we were to rank based on a one-time matchup, imagine the daisy-chain generated polls that would result. The Boyle County-St. Edward game is another one that I think could have different outcomes in a rematch. I realize that it was a seventeen-point margin, but find it hard to believe that BC is seventeen points better than St. Edward. But as I have said many times, the season will bear out the truth on both teams. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
elKakador Posted September 11 Share Posted September 11 Does On3.com rankings come out of Texas? They have 7 of the top 10 teams from there on their list... 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GardenStateBaller Posted September 11 Share Posted September 11 8 minutes ago, elKakador said: Does On3.com rankings come out of Texas? They have 7 of the top 10 teams from there on their list... It's the bad Massey poll they use. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GardenStateBaller Posted September 11 Share Posted September 11 8 hours ago, whiteshoes1212 said: Unlike the DePaul-Good Counsel game, this is one that I firmly believe was an outlier. If we were to rank based on a one-time matchup, imagine the daisy-chain generated polls that would result. The Boyle County-St. Edward game is another one that I think could have different outcomes in a rematch. I realize that it was a seventeen-point margin, but find it hard to believe that BC is seventeen points better than St. Edward. But as I have said many times, the season will bear out the truth on both teams. That there thinking is one of the reasons we created our own rankings two years ago. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
elKakador Posted September 11 Share Posted September 11 11 minutes ago, GardenStateBaller said: It's the bad Massey poll they use. Does the Massey rankings come out of Texas? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
GardenStateBaller Posted September 11 Share Posted September 11 15 minutes ago, elKakador said: Does the Massey rankings come out of Texas? No idea, but he def has a case of Texas Derangement Syndrome. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.